Exercises › Compare › Barbell shrug vs Smith machine shrug
Exercise comparison · Back

Barbell shrug vs Smith machine shrug: which should you do?

Muscles, equipment, difficulty and sets side by side, with the demo for each from the GymAdapt AI app.

Short answer

Results are similar. The Smith version is easier to set up for heavy sets. Pick the barbell shrug if you want a free-weight shrug. Pick the Smith machine shrug if you want a fixed path and no deadlift from the floor to set up.

FREE ON IPHONE & ANDROID

GymAdapt is free to use. No trial, no subscription needed.

  • An AI plan for your goal, days and equipment
  • Unlimited workouts and set logging
  • A video for every exercise
  • Weights that adjust for you (first 30 days)
Get it freeGoogle PlayFree to $29.99/yr. iPhone and Android.

Side by side

Barbell shrugSmith machine shrug
Main musclesTrapsTraps
Also worksForearms (grip)Forearms (grip)
EquipmentBarbellSmith machine
LevelBeginnerBeginner
TypeIsolation (one joint)Isolation (one joint)
Typical sets × reps3 × 10–153 × 10–15
Rest between sets60–90 s60–90 s

Which one should you pick?

Pick the barbell shrug if…You want a free-weight shrug.
Pick the Smith machine shrug if…You want a fixed path and no deadlift from the floor to set up.

How to do the barbell shrug

1
Hold the bar. Hands shoulder width, arms straight, bar against your thighs.
2
Stand tall. Chest up, knees soft, eyes forward.
3
Shrug straight up. Lift the shoulders toward the ears without bending the elbows.

Full barbell shrug guide: all steps, mistakes and alternatives →

How to do the Smith machine shrug

1
Set the bar height. Hooks at about mid-thigh so you do not have to deadlift it up.
2
Grip and unhook. Hands shoulder width, rotate the bar out of the hooks.
3
Shrug straight up. The fixed track keeps the bar path vertical.

Full Smith machine shrug guide: all steps, mistakes and alternatives →

More comparisons

Questions people ask

Is the barbell shrug better than the Smith machine shrug?

Results are similar. The Smith version is easier to set up for heavy sets.

Do the barbell shrug and Smith machine shrug work the same muscles?

Yes, largely. Both train the forearms, grip, traps.

Which is better for beginners?

Both are rated beginner. Start with whichever equipment you have and learn the movement with light weight.

Can I do the barbell shrug and Smith machine shrug in the same workout?

Yes. A common setup is one as your main back exercise early in the workout and the other later for extra volume. Avoid doing both to failure on the same day if they hit the same muscles hard.

FOR READERS OF THIS PAGE

GymAdapt is free to start. Want Pro free for a month?

The free version gives you an AI-built plan and unlimited workouts. Code TRYFREE01 adds a full month of Pro on top: weights that adjust from what you log and unlimited coach chats.

Redeem the free month → Opens the App Store with the code filled in. iPhone only. After the month it's $5.99/mo unless you cancel in Settings, and the free version stays yours either way.

Not sure which to do? GymAdapt AI picks for your goal and equipment.

Swap any exercise in one tap, see the demo, and get next session’s weight from what you logged.

Get GymAdapt AI on the App Store →Get GymAdapt on Google Play → Free to start. Pro is $5.99 a month or $29.99 a year (7-day free trial), or $59.99 once for lifetime. iPhone and Android.
About this page. General training information, not medical advice. GymAdapt AI is our app.